Home Francais E-mail Animanga - Anime and Manga Services






Search :



Subject:
From:
URL:
E-mail:
Re: no complaints here, but a question is raised.. (Mon Jul 10 09:06:39 2000 )
aethel

brokenthelly@hotmail.com

I myself have used the deputy service both for yahoo japan 
and for ordering from japanese web sites... and have been 
very pleased with the speed and service recieved, just to 
vouch for it.  But now that it is common knowledge (I like
 the others here didnt talk about it because I felt 
like "if it's important enough to them, they can follow the
 link themselves") it raises an issue (one that probably 
needs to be discussed with mr. sato):  What happens (as it 
inevitably will) when 2 people both want the same cel on 
yahoo japan?  I mean.. you cant bid against eachother since 
he places the bid for you, but otherwise how do you resolve
 who gets the cel? I have no problem with the fact that if
 one person sends him a max bid of 10000(yen) and another
 of 12000 the cel might still only go for 5000 and not 10000 as it would if they bid directly against eachother, 
since the seller closed their auction to foreign bids and 
wouldnt be getting either of them if this service wasnt 
available..but what bothers me is that this means one of 
two solutions is going to occur:

A- the person who sends the highest bid to the deputy 
service is the one that is bid for, and regardless of how 
much under that max bid they sent the cel sells for, they 
are the one who gets it.   The problem with this becomes
 there is nothing to prevent someone from giving an 
absolutely insane high bid, knowing that chances are good 
they will never have to pay that much.

B- the first person to send in a request for the cel is the
 one bid for.  The problem with this becomes what if the 
person who sends in the request had a very low max bid and
 gets outbid... someone else might have had a higher one 
and might have won the auction if they had gotten their bid in first. not only that but it turns yahoo japan into a 
race (not that getting cels from other store type sources 
isn't, but you see my point)  I'm not expecting anyone here 
to really do anything about this issue, since ultimately
 its up to mr. sato, but I was just wondering if anyone 
could think of some good suggestions.



[ Back to Cels Forum ]


Message thread :


Copyright ©2000 Yann Stettler and CohProg Sarl. All rights reserved. Privacy statement