Home Francais E-mail Animanga - Anime and Manga Services






Search :



Subject:
From:
URL:
E-mail:
Re: bootleggers... (OT, please don't kill me :P) (Mon Aug 28 18:04:25 2000 )
oion


I don't know much about VCD's.... but as for 
music CD's, Son May, Everanime, Archer, and 
possibly York (??) are Taiwanese companies and 
according to *a store owner* that my mom asked in 
Taipei, these are legal in Taiwan as well - but 
only in Taiwan (i.e. selling for profit outside 
the country is illegal due to a special 
contract?). Obviously I'd be wary of the source of 
such information, but it's incredibly easy to ID 
bootleg stuff - when it's in front of your face. 
^_^' CD's are easier to ID on evilBay because 
scans should immediately show that the 
copyright/distributor holder is not the original 
Japanese company (and "Taiwan" would be on the CD 
case). Posters, wallscrolls, shitajiki, and idol 
cards are also easily ID'd when fully visible 
because there's no copyright, no publisher 
sticker, and the quality is generally crappier. Of
course, you'd still have to see the damn thing...
I certainly wouldn't dream of paying $15 for a 
bootleg SM CD when I can get it in Taiwan for $3..
^_^' (But that's another story) 

Also, Japanese anime companies do seem much more 
lax about enforcing copyright issues in other 
asian countries (whether it's a technical 
difficulty, I don't know). An interesting thing 
is that in certain cases I don't believe this 
would harm them. Look at all the fan sites with 
image galleries, for instance. You wouldn't see 
*any* such sites for Disney, Fox, or possibly WB, 
but the particular medium of still images is taken
as "public" by fans at large. No cracking down. In 
this case it's probably just free advertising.(?)
Yes, video and music are different, and I get 
pissed too when I see these absolutely obvious 
bootlegs on auction, but the only thing we can do 
is complain to the evilBay higher-ups, and do 
what we can to educate every potential fan ...



[ Back to Cels Forum ]


Message thread :


Copyright ©2000 Yann Stettler and CohProg Sarl. All rights reserved. Privacy statement